"Should I start the business?"

Ben had been describing the same business to friends for about three years. A name, a rough plan, two people who had said they would come in on it, and a notebook that got opened whenever work was bad. Nothing had been registered, nothing built, nothing sold. The plan was to hand in notice in January.

Should I start the business?

The card

Ace of Wands, reversed — a false start, delay, the spark not catching.

The enthusiasm is there and nothing has caught yet. Either the timing is off or the idea needs more than enthusiasm.

The card came out upside down, which is why it is printed that way here. The upright Ace of Wands is the spark itself; reversed, it is the same spark, still in the hand, still not having lit anything.

The short answer

Perhaps

The reading

A hand comes out of a cloud holding a budding branch, and everything about the upright card is potential — the moment before, the match struck. Turn it over and none of that potential goes away. It simply stays potential, which is the most precise thing anyone could say about a business that has existed in a notebook for three years.

So the perhaps is pointed at the January plan rather than at the idea. The card is not telling you the business is bad; it has no view on that. It is telling you that nothing has caught yet, and that handing in notice is not a way of making something catch — it is a way of removing your income while you find out. Three years of enthusiasm has produced no evidence, and the reversed Ace is asking, fairly bluntly, why not.

The two people who said they would come in on it are worth a hard look here, because said they would is the reversed Ace in human form. There is a version of this where you ask them for one afternoon each in November and discover whether the thing has three people in it or one. That afternoon costs you nothing and answers more than the notebook has in three years. The version where you resign first and find out in February is the same discovery at a much worse price.

What would turn this card upright is not more certainty, it is one piece of real contact with the world. The smallest complete version of the business — one customer, one paid job, one thing actually sold to somebody who is not a friend — done in evenings while the salary is still arriving. That is not a delay tactic and it is not the cautious option; it is the only thing that distinguishes an idea from a business, and it is what the card is asking for by name.

Notice as well when the notebook gets opened. A plan that surfaces whenever work is bad may be a business, or it may be the shape your dissatisfaction takes on a Thursday. Those want different responses, and one evening of trying to sell something will tell you which you have far more reliably than another year of description.

What this one shows

Reversed does not mean no. It usually means not like this, and the reading's job is to say what the this is. Here it was the order of operations — the card had no objection to the business and a great deal to say about resigning before it existed.

A story, not a transcript. Ben is invented and so is the notebook; the question is the shape people really ask in.

← Should I tell her what I know? · All ten stories · Should we buy the house? →