"Is he still thinking about me?"

Chloe had been broken up with in March and had spent the summer being fine in company and not fine at eleven at night. The last message either of them sent was in April. What the question wanted was not really an answer. It was permission to keep the door open.

Is he still thinking about me?

The card

The Moon, upright — uncertainty, illusion, things unclear.

You are not seeing this straight, and neither is anyone else. The Moon is half-light, where familiar shapes look like something else. Do not make an irreversible decision on what you can currently make out.

The short answer

No

The reading

Before anything else: that no is the card's polarity, not a report on him. No card knows what another person thinks, and a reading that told you it did would be making it up. This one will not. What The Moon has come up to say is that the question you asked cannot be answered from where you are standing, and it says it with unusual force.

Look at what is in the picture. A path runs from the water to the horizon between two towers, and either side of it a dog and a wolf are howling at the same moon. The point of that pairing is that in this light you cannot tell which is which. The Moon is not the card of bad news. It is the card of insufficient light — the hour when the shape at the end of the garden is either a bush or a person and you genuinely cannot tell, and when the wise move is not to decide but to wait for morning.

Which is exactly the position you are in, and the reason no answer to this question would help you. If a card said yes, you would spend a week reading it as a promise and refreshing a thread that has been still since April. If it said no, you would take it as a verdict on your worth from a picture printed in 1909. Both of those hand something that belongs to you to something that cannot hold it. The honest version is that he may think about you often, or rarely, or in a way that has nothing to do with coming back, and that no arrangement of his thoughts changes what your autumn is going to be made of.

There is a question underneath this one that a card can actually meet, and you already know its shape: what do I do with the door I have been holding open. That one has evidence available. Six months, no contact since April, a decision he made and has not revisited. That is not a reading of his heart, it is just the record, and it is the only thing here you can see clearly enough to act on.

So take the card as being about your visibility rather than his feelings. In half-light you do not choose, you do not conclude, and you do not send anything you would not want read back to you in daylight. You wait, and you notice that the eleven-at-night version of this has been telling you things about him it cannot possibly know either.

What this one shows

Some questions are unanswerable, and the useful thing a reading can do is say so and then hand you the answerable one underneath. The whole of yes or no tarot says the same in general terms; this is what it looks like on a specific evening. If you are carrying something heavier than a question about a card, please talk to someone who can actually help.

A story, not a transcript. Chloe is invented and so is the summer; the question is one of the most-asked shapes there is.

← Should I text him first? · All ten stories · Should I move back home? →